djnaff2020's pick · Updated July 2026
WITHINGS Body Smart

I keep this scale in the bathroom where I can step on it first thing without thinking about it, and that is probably the main reason I like it. It is for the person who is trying to lose weight and wants more than a single number once in a while. If you do better when you can see a pattern instead of guessing, this kind of scale makes sense. It gives you a steady read on weight and body composition without making the whole thing feel like homework.
What I like most is that it does more than the cheap scale I had before. That old one gave me a number and not much else, so it was easy to ignore the rest of the week. This one gives you a fuller picture, and that helps when you are trying to be honest with yourself. Even on days when the scale number is not exactly where I want it, I can still see that I am paying attention and that matters. The app side is useful too. Once it is set up, it keeps track of the readings in a way that is easy to look back on, and I do like that I do not have to write anything down or remember what I saw last time.
The body fat reading is the part that will matter most to some people and less to others. I treat it as a trend, not a verdict. That is the right way to use a scale like this. It helps me notice whether the overall direction is moving the way I want, even when day to day water weight makes the number bounce around. If you go in expecting a perfect medical result from a bathroom scale, you will probably be annoyed. If you use it as a tool for staying aware, it is helpful.
One small thing I would change is that the first setup takes a little more patience than I wanted. Getting the app linked and making sure the readings show up the way they should is not hard, but it is not instant either. You have to pay attention the first time through. After that, it is much smoother. I also wish the display stayed lit a little longer, just because I like to glance at the reading before I step off and the screen goes away faster than I would choose.
I started paying closer attention to my habits once I had a scale that gave me more than a single blunt number. That is really what this is good for. It sits there quietly, it gives you useful information, and it does not take up much space. I appreciate that it works with the health setup on my phone, because that keeps everything in one place instead of spread across a bunch of random notes and half-finished plans.
If you are trying to lose weight and you want a bathroom scale that helps you stay consistent instead of just occasionally frustrated, this is a good one to have. It is especially useful for someone who wants the tracking side without buying a separate gadget for everything. I would recommend it to anyone who wants a more complete picture of their progress and is willing to treat the readings like part of a routine, not a magic answer.
Amazon product links on this guide are not currently affiliate links. Neither djnaff2020 nor Buyer Field Guide earns an affiliate commission from them.
See current price